https://hal-univ-pau.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02153544Gallipoli, DomenicoDomenicoGallipoliSIAME - Laboratoire des Sciences de l'Ingénieur Appliquées à la Mécanique et au génie Electrique - UPPA - Université de Pau et des Pays de l'AdourGrassl, PeterPeterGrasslUniversity of GlasgowWheeler, SimonSimonWheelerGens, AntonioAntonioGensOn the Choice of Stress\textendashStrain Variables for Unsaturated Soils and Its Effect on Plastic FlowHAL CCSD2018Unsaturated soilsEffective stressElasto-plasticityPlastic flowSuctionWork input[PHYS] Physics [physics]Labo, SIAME2019-06-12 12:01:112021-03-19 09:10:052019-06-12 12:01:11enJournal articles10.1016/j.gete.2018.02.0021The net stress plus suction and the average skeleton stress plus modified suction are two alternative sets of energetically consistent stress variables for modelling the hydro-mechanical behaviour of unsaturated soils. When used in conjunction with their work-conjugate strains, both sets of stress variables correctly calculate the first-order term of the hydro-mechanical work input into a soil element subjected to infinitesimal changes of deformation and water content. They therefore also correctly calculate the increment of internal energy along a given stress\textendashstrain path, that is the integral of the first-order term of the infinitesimal work input. This paper shows, however, that the above two sets of stress variables lead to different values of the second-order term of the hydro-mechanical work input. They are therefore no longer equivalent with respect to other aspects of material behaviour governed by the second-order work such as the flow rule of elasto-plastic models. The flow rule assumes the normality between plastic strains and equipotential surfaces defined in the conjugate stress\textendashstrain space. This normality is however lost when an elasto-plastic model originally formulated in terms of net stress plus suction is recast in terms of average skeleton stress plus modified suction (or vice versa) by means of standard mapping relationships between stress variables. To restore normality in both stress spaces, it is necessary to impose specific forms of elastic and plastic behaviour. \textcopyright 2018 Elsevier Ltd